John Healey resigns: ‘Massive body blow’ as PM loses his defence secretary – and another departure follows | Politics News

Sir Keir Starmer has been dealt a double blow to his authority with the resignations of his defence secretary and armed forces minister.

The departure of John Healey from the top post has been labelled a “massive body blow” to the prime minister by the former Labour deputy leader Harriet Harman. His exit was followed hours later by Al Carns, who quit soon after a live interview with Sky News.

As it happened: Healey and Carns quit government

Baroness Harman said Mr Healey’s departure “pulls the rug” from under the view that Sir Keir – who has struggled at home – has been a success on foreign policy.

Sir Keir has sought to take a leading role on issues such as a potential post-war peacekeeping force in Ukraine, and weaning NATO’s European members off reliance on the US.

Baroness Harman was speaking to Sky News political editor Beth Rigby on the Electoral Dysfunction podcast hours after Mr Healey announced his resignation over the prime minister’s spending plans for transforming the armed forces.

👉 Tap here to listen to Electoral Dysfunction on your podcast app 👈

In his damning resignation letter, the now ex-defence secretary told the prime minister: “This era for defence required further investment through the defence investment plan.

“The excellent and extensive cross-government work that completed in January – overseen by you, me and the chancellor – confirmed the scale of the challenge and the rising demands on defence.

“Since then, you have been unable, and the Treasury has been unwilling, to commit the resources that the nation needs to defend the country at this time of rising threats.”

Mr Healey has been replaced by former security minister Dan Jarvis.

Share

Why Healey’s ‘extraordinary’ resignation leaves PM in ‘perilous bind’

Mr Carns also submitted a resignation letter on Thursday night, saying “it has become clear to me that the change I had pushed for is not going to come”.

Appearing on Sky’s The Cathy Newman show less than an hour before, he said the prime minister’s defence spending plan “isn’t enough”, and he “wasn’t happy with the level of transformation in it”.

PM touts ‘unprecedented’ defence boost

Sir Keir has defended his defence investment plan, the publication of which has been delayed for months, prompting concern from military chiefs and industry leaders.

In his response to Mr Healey’s letter, Sir Keir described the plan as “an unprecedented increase in defence spending in a sustainable way”.

Sky News understands the Treasury has offered the Ministry of Defence (MoD) around an additional £13bn over four years to help fund the purchase of new jets, submarines, ships, drones and missiles.

As reported by security and defence editor Deborah Haynes, this is at the lower end of a range of between £12bn and £18bn that had been under consideration – and far short of the actual sum of extra money that the military believes it needs to rebuild its hollowed-out ranks at a time of escalating threats.

UK under mounting pressure over defence spending

Deborah Haynes

Security and Defence Editor

@haynesdeborah

A gap in funding to rebuild the Royal Navy, army and Royal Air Force was already thought to be at least £28bn before new expectations were added following the publication of a sweeping view of defence last June.

Upping the pressure is wider war in the Middle East and increased demands by Donald Trump for the UK and other European NATO allies to take up a much greater level of responsibility for their own defences.

The UK presents itself as a leading member of the alliance. Yet it does not plan to hit a new NATO target to increase defence spending to 3.5% of GDP from the UK’s current level of around 2.3% until 2035 – the furthest possible date that allies set to achieve the new funding baseline.

Last year’s Strategic Defence Review was meant to be the defining document on the armed forces of the Starmer government, outlining the prime minister’s stated desire to rearm.

It should have been followed last autumn by the defence investment plan, which would explain how the vision would be funded. But disagreement on the size of the uplift meant the publication date has been repeatedly pushed back.

The prime minister has promised to release it before a NATO summit on 7 and 8 July.

See also  UK to 'war-game' how frontline British troops could be equipped with weapons amid supply chain disruption | Politics News

Advertisements

Share

What does the UK spend on defence?

Healey ‘a big loss’

Baroness Harman described Mr Healey’s resignation as “a massive body blow”.

She said: “The thing about John Healey is he was regarded as a very successful defence secretary, commanding the respect and confidence of the armed forces; a good communicator about what was going on in the armed services; and, I think, well respected by Labour MPs and across the House [of Commons].

“And also, he was not seen as a schemer or a plotter, not out for his own interests [or] trying to do things to advance his leadership potential, but just a loyal and dedicated cabinet member in the position of secretary of state for defence. And so that makes him a big loss.”

Baroness Harman knows Mr Healey well – the pair served together in parliament from 1997 to 2024 and were in Ed Miliband’s shadow cabinet together from 2010 to 2011.

More on defence:
Could a drone cause UK blackouts?
‘Almost 500,000’ Russians killed in Ukraine
Why is public being kept in dark about threat of war?

On what her former colleague’s resignation means, Baroness Harman said: “Often people would have said about Keir Starmer, ‘Well, he hasn’t done so well back here in this country, but what he’s done abroad, what he’s done on defence, has worked’. He’s been seen as a good and successful figure. In NATO, he stood up well on decisions in relation to Ukraine.

“And so to have this criticism about how he’s worked on the non-domestic things pulls the rug out from under his feet on what he’s done abroad, as well as the problems that he’s faced here at home.”

Shr went on to say that Mr Healey’s resignation “puts more pressure on Rachel Reeves” as chancellor because people will be asking why she didn’t “come up with the spending that was necessary”.

But more broadly, the former deputy Labour leader said: “Keir Starmer himself has said the first duty of the prime minister is to keep the country safe. And what John Healey said in his resignation letter is that you are making the country less safe. And that’s why it’s so devastating.”