Flintshire toddler death: Murdered toddler treated worse than animal

A couple accused of murdering their two-year-old grandson, who died from a catastrophic brain injury, treated him with “casual brutality”, a court has heard.

Ethan Ives Griffiths was discovered “severely underweight, covered in bruises”, after he was allegedly murdered by his grandparents, Michael and Kerry Ives in Garden City, Flintshire, on 16 August 2021.

Mr Ives, 46, and Mrs Ives, 45, are charged with murder, causing or allowing the death of a child, and cruelty to a child – which they deny.

At their trial at Mold Crown Court on Wednesday, the prosecutor said the other children had been encouraged to mistreat Ethan as “play”.

Ethan’s mother, Shannon Ives, 28, of Mold, Flintshire, is charged with causing or allowing the death of a child, and cruelty to a child. She also denied the charges.

The court heard Ethan, his mother Shannon, and some other children were living with her parents in the summer of 2021.

Opening the prosecution’s case, Caroline Rees KC said: “[Ethan] was quiet and withdrawn, small and painfully thin”, by the time of his death.

He was targeted as an object of “abuse and neglect,” and in the run-up to his death, experienced “distress, pain and misery”.

He collapsed on 14 August 2021 after a “forceful attack” by those that should have cared for him most, the jury was told.

The prosecution said Mr and Mrs Ives were the only ones with him when he was assaulted, and his mother Shannon was upstairs on her phone.

His mother is not charged with murder, but the prosecution claimed she was aware he was at risk, and “did nothing to protect him from that risk”.

Following the assault, his grandparents entered “a pact of silence as to what they did to Ethan that night”.

They chose instead, to blame their daughter, the court heard.

Ms Rees added: “They both had something serious to hide, namely that they were both involved in causing his death.”

She said Ethan was the victim of an assault on a “vulnerable, defenceless child,” and added he was “treated with casual brutality by the people trusted to protect him.”

Ethan was unconscious after the alleged assault on 14 August.

He was taken to Alder Hey Children’s’ Hospital in Liverpool, but never regained consciousness.

The court heard one paramedic described him as looking “like a 90-year-old man”, and gaunt.

Examinations in intensive care showed multiple bruises to his face and body, and there was a “range of significant injuries to Ethan’s eyes”.

There was evidence of shaken baby syndrome, the court heard, highly suggestive of “abusive head trauma”.

The court heard Ethan was found to have high levels of sodium – indicative of dehydration.

The jury saw a series of CCTV clips, taken from a CCTV camera installed in the Ives’ garden.

In multiple clips, Ethan appears to be struggling for balance, while two other children bounce around him.

In several clips, he lies on his side, and despite getting to his feet, is seen to fall repeatedly.

At one point, his mother Shannon climbed on the trampoline and bounced, causing Ethan to fall.

One of the children is much older and bigger than Ethan, and bounces “forcefully”, while Ethan flops around, “like a rag doll”, the prosecution said.

All three defendants were in the garden, but “not a single one of them stops it”, Ms Rees said.

In one clip, a child picks Ethan up by is feet. In multiple clips, Ethan is seen lying on his side, flopping around while other children bounce up and down.

Later, Michael Ives is seen to pick Ethan by one arm from the trampoline, carrying him back to the house.

“His handling of that obviously unwell and frail child is cruel”, and you would not have treated an animal that way, Ms Rees said.

In one clip, Michael Ives looks towards a child and raises his fist. The child then appears to strike Ethan on the head, several times.

Michael Ives is also seen walking over to the trampoline and putting Ethan’s hands on his head, as he sat.

As the children continued to bounce around, Ethan is seen trying to keep his hands on his head, even after falling.

Neither Kerry Ives nor Shannon Ives showed “even a jot of concern or care”, the prosecutor said.

The trail continues.