England vs New Zealand player ratings: Matt Henry stands head and shoulders above in difficult Test for Jacob Bethell and James Rew

Ben Duckett – 4

Looked in good touch with a fluent 36 off 25 balls before he was barbecued by his opening partner during a run out in the first innings. Gave his wicket away cheaply in the chase.

Emilio Gay – 5

Showed his battling qualities with a dogged half-century in the first innings – England’s top score – and deserves a run in the side.

Jacob Bethell – 3

After scores of six and 14 at Lord’s the 22-year-old made nine and nought, which underlined an obvious rustiness for the longer format given his lack of red-ball cricket. Claimed some handy wickets with the ball, but questions persist of his suitability to bat at number three.

Joe Root – 6

Became only the second player to reach 14,000 Test runs with 77 in the second innings and England held faint hope while he was at the crease. However, this was a largely miserable return to captaincy.

Harry Brook – 5

A flashy half-century in the second innings entertained the crowd on Saturday, but this was an occasion England needed him to deliver a big hundred of substance against the odds.

James Rew – 3

Looked a little out of his depth on debut. There were some glimpses of promise with the bat during knocks of 24 and 15, but dropped chances with the gloves, which reflected the fact his wicketkeeping still needs to be polished.

Jordan Cox – 4

The temperament to play Test cricket largely looked to be there, even if his scores of 27 and 25 did not set the world alight.

Jofra Archer – 7

England’s best player. Bowled some ferociously quick spells that unsettled New Zealand’s batters and gave England belief they could wrestle their way back into the match. Deserved more than five wickets.

Matthew Fisher – 6

Never gave anything less than 100%. Grafted a determined half-century in a tail-end rescue act to keep England in the game and stuck to his plans to build pressure with the ball during tough periods.

Josh Tongue – 5

A player considered England’s strike bowler had his moments but was not quite able to make the kind of impact on the contest he would have liked.

Sonny Baker – 5

Modest returns on his debut but there were signs he has the pace, skills and character to cut it on the international stage at some stage down the line.