South Africa: ‘Our children are dying, but President Ramaphosa doesn’t care’


Poster saying 'bring back to the death penaltyImage copyright
Getty Images

In our series of letters from African journalists, South African filmmaker and writer Serusha Govender reports on the growing anger fuelled by a spate of child murders.

Passing by Cape Town’s Parliament Square earlier this month, I caught sight of Fadiel Adams camped outside on the final days of a hunger strike.

This was a father making a desperate stand against what he felt was the government’s lack of interest in combating the recent spate of child murders in the Western Cape province.

The child murder rate has been high for some time in South Africa, but since the beginning of the year, several killings close to Cape Town have drawn nationwide fury and calls for immediate action.

The murder of seven-year-old Tazne van Wyk in early February was the spark.

Fadiel Adams

Sakeena Frenchman

If we have to shut down this whole city to make our point next time then we will”

Tazne went missing on 7 February. Her body was found two weeks later after her suspected murderer led police to the storm drain where he said he had disposed of it.

The suspect, a violent multiple offender had been released on parole. He was in prison for the kidnapping and murder of another child.

Mr Adams ended his hunger strike after six days, once he had handed a memorandum to President Cyril Ramaphosa’s secretary, but his campaign is far from over.

‘We are dying here’

He is not convinced that the president will do anything. He accused the president of not caring, adding that “this government has failed all of us”.

“We are dying here, our children are dying,” said Mr Adams.

“If Ramaphosa really cared he would have made an immediate directive… I don’t condone violence or burning things, but we won’t stop raising this [issue]. If we have to shut down this whole city to make our point next time then we will.”

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

In February, President Ramaphosa tried to reassure the angry crowd in Elsies River

After Tazne’s body was found, Mr Ramaphosa visited her community in Elsies River and apologised.

He said that the accused should never have been given parole, adding that he knew how the community felt and that urgent action would be taken.

His words were reminiscent of his speech to protesting crowds outside parliament after a 19-year-old student, Uyinene Mrwetyana, was murdered by a postal worker last year.

This triggered nationwide protests against the high levels of violence against women and children, which in turn prompted the president to promise immediate targeted action.

Then, too, Mr Ramaphosa told the crowds that this should never have happened, that he would take action, and that he knew how they felt.

But following Tazne’s killing, his audience had had enough of platitudes, with many saying that they wanted less smooth-talking and more real action being taken to keep their children safe.

Child murders in South Africa

And they are right to be concerned as Cape Town does seem to have a high number of child murders, and it appears to be getting worse.

Crime statistics released last year showed that four children are murdered every week in the Western Cape Province alone and, overall, child murders have increased across the country by almost 30% over a decade.

On the same day that Tazne went missing, seven-year-old Reagan Gertse disappeared. His body was discovered on a farm in the Western Cape a week later. The man accused of killing Reagan was also a violent criminal released on parole.

Serusha Govender

Serusha Govender

The government should not be too surprised when affected communities lose faith and lash out”

And there have been other cases of people on parole committing murder.

When the president promises to fix the problem by pouring more money into a criminal justice system that is releasing violent criminals into communities without any warning, the government should not be too surprised when those communities lose faith and lash out.

When the man accused of killing Tazne appeared in court, community members revolted. They attempted to storm the court building and, when that failed, they torched nearby buildings they said were frequented by neighbourhood criminals, including the accused.

Community Activist Mr Adams said that no-one wanted to mete out vigilante justice.

“To be honest their reaction was mild in comparison to the violence this community has already faced… How else did you expect them to express their anger and frustration at what’s been happening?” he asked.

You may also be interested in:

Albert Frtiz, the politician in charge of community safety in the Western Cape, acknowledges that the criminal justice system has failed its residents, and the parole system faces profound issues.

At the national level, Justice Minister Ronald Lomola has defended parole, saying that most of the people released are reintegrated safely back into society.

While he admitted that there were flaws in the system, he said it was not entirely broken.

Perhaps the level of child murder here is symptomatic of a much deeper malaise and arguing over the parole issue is missing the bigger point.

But what is certain is that there are too many children dying here and the government is not doing enough to protect them.

More Letters from Africa

Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica





BBC News

Leave a Reply